Authors | Louisa Kramer |
Compilation date | 02 September 2024 |
Customer | Heathrow Airport Limited |
Approved by | Nick Rand |
Copyright | Ricardo Energy & Environment |
EULA | Ricardo Report EULA |
Contract reference | ED16726 | Report reference | UFP Summary - Aug 2024 |
Heathrow Airport Limited have commissioned Ricardo to undertake a monitoring programme to investigate the concentrations of ultrafine particles (UFP) at Heathrow Airport.
WHO defines UFPs as particles greater than 10 nm in size. UFP are usually so small that they contribute very little to these mass measurements, so they are typically reported as the number of particles in a volume of air.
There are currently no national limits in place for UFPs, however, the World Health Organization (WHO) published a “good practice statement”1 for UFPs, with thresholds associated with HIGH and LOW concentrations.
HIGH concentrations: 24-hour mean > 10,000 particles/cm3 (24-hour mean) or 1-hour mean > 20,000 particles/cm3
LOW concentrations: 24-hour mean < 1,000 particles/cm3 (24-hour mean)
This report presents preliminary data and analysis for the period 22nd April 2023 to 31st December 2023.
A Condensation Particle Counter (CPC) was installed at the LHR2 monitoring station in April 2023. LHR2 is an on-airport airside location station, situated inside the northern perimeter fence on an area of the old apron between the northern runway and the northern perimeter road, 14.5 m from the kerb and 179 m from the runway centre. The prevailing wind direction is from the south west and hence this site, situated to the north east of the airport, was selected to monitor air pollutants arising from the airport area. Although there are no EU limit values and UK AQS objectives for UFP it is worth noting, for the main relevant ambient air quality pollutants these limit values and objectives only apply to locations where public exposure may occur. As LHR2 is located within the airport perimeter, where members of the public do not have access, these limits do not apply.
The CPC measures ultrafine particle number concentrations down to 10 nm, meeting the requirements of the WHO “good practice statement”. Currently, there is no specification for particle size distribution, particle speciation, principle of operation or measurement uncertainty within the WHO guidance.
A datalogging system records values from the CPC every second. From these spot values, aggregated 1 minute values are calculated and logged, hourly and 24-hourly mean averages were subsequently then calculated. It should be noted that 1 second data above 100,000 particles/cm3 are higher than the range of the instrument, therefore these readings have a much higher associated uncertainty.
It is worth noting, and as you will see within this report, a high proportion of the recorded measurements are above the instruments accurate working range. In terms of the overall monitoring survey, the analyser is able to assess whether the WHO guidelines are breached at the LHR2 location, however measuring an accurate background concentration appears not to be possible with the current sampling infrastructure. There are potential enhancements that can be made to the instrumentation (by way of installing a dilution system) to enable a background concentration to be defined more accurately. This should be considered for the continuation of the survey, depending on HAL’s overall objectives.
The plot below shows the timeseries of hourly averaged particle number (PN) concentrations measured at LHR2. The green line represents hourly averages calculated from all the 1 minute values, the blue line represents hourly averages that have been filtered to remove data that contains 1 second spot values above the value of 100,000 particles/cm3, as there is greater uncertainty in the data above this threshold.
Daily averaged filtered data from London Heathrow has been compared to data from London Honor Oak Park and London Marylebone Road, over the same period. Both sites are part of the UK Particle Concentrations and Numbers (PCN) Network. Chilbolton Observatory is also part of the PCN Network, however the data capture for particle number concentration was less than 10% in 2023, so has been excluded from the analysis.
Concentrations observed at Heathrow are similar to those measured at Marylebone Road (a roadside site), whereas at Honor Oak Park (an urban background site) concentrations are much lower.
The plots below show how particle number concentrations vary over different time intervals (diurnal, day of week and month of year). The filtered data set is used in the calculation. The topmost frame shows the concentrations as they vary by hour of the day and day of the week. The hour of the day variation is summarised on its own in the lower left pane and the variation by day of the week is shown in the lower right pane.
The diurnal cycles show that particle number concentrations increase during the daytime with a minimum at night. Elevated concentrations over a few hours are observed in the morning, noon and evening. Concentrations vary throughtout the week, with the highest concentrations observed on a Sunday and the lowest on Thursdays.
The map below shows a polar plot for particle number concentration at LHR2. The polar plot helps to understand the relative strength and direction of sources. The distance from the plot origin shows the wind speed.
The highest particle number concentrations are observed when the wind direction is from the southwest/west, under low to moderate wind speeds (2-15 ms-1).
The table below provides a summary of UFP measurements for the reporting period, and comparison with the WHO guidelines. Statistics for both the filtered and unfiltered data sets are shown here. Also shown are statistics from the UK Particle Concentrations and Numbers Network (PCN Network) for 2023.
The data capture rate for the measurements at Heathrow during the period presented here is 94.9%. The comparison with the WHO guidelines (for unfiltered data) shows that the 1 hour mean exceeded the WHO guideline on 228 days out of a total of 256 days of measurements. The 24 hour mean WHO guideline was exceeded on 231 days.
Box 4.2. Good practice statement – UFP: WHO global air quality guidelines (available at: https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/345329/9789240034228-eng.pdf?isAllowed=y&sequence=1)↩︎
Name | Nick Rand |
Address | Ricardo Energy & Environment, Gemini Building, Harwell, Didcot, OX11 0QR, United Kingdom |
Telephone | 01235 753484 |
nick.rand@ricardo.com |